NEWS: Expensive iTunes accused of breaking European law

Apple has been courting controversy this week, receiving criticism on several fronts about its service to iTunes users, as well as early adopters of Apple TV.

The European Commission (EC) is currently questioning Apple, along with several major record labels, as to why we in the UK pay more for music bought from the iTunes Music store than anyone else in Europe. While a single track typically costs 79 pence in the UK, the same song will set any other European citizen back 99 cents - or 0.99 Euros - which equates to around 68p at current exchange rates. That's a price difference of 18 per cent.

The investigation is a response to a complaint to the Office Of Fair Trading, and subsequently to the European Commission, which alleges that the current Apple pricing system breaks European law.

Apple's policy works by forcing British users to buy from the British store: users trying to by music from, say, the German iTunes store are prevented from doing so by the company's credit card registration system.

The European Commission's 'statement of objection' is forcing Apple to defend its pricing policy, and alleges that the site's national restrictions break European rules preventing restrictive business practices.

And if that wasn't enough, the good news that Apple started selling DRM-free music on the iTunes store has been tempered somewhat by the revelation that the DRM-free files contain the name and email address of the person who bought them. Apple has remained tight-lipped about the reason for this, prompting accusations that it is a 'backdoor' anti-piracy measure.

In addition, the news that Apple was launching a second-generation Apple TV so soon after the first version has been criticised by early adopters. Some users have complained that the new 160GB unit makes their recently purchased 40GB version look like very poor value.

In better news for Apple, the American release of the much-awaited iPhone has been set for June 29th, increasing chances that we in the UK will see the new music player/mobile phone hybrid before the end of the year.

Apple's prospects for the European iPhone release have also been boosted by rumours that Microsoft's iPod rival, the Zune, will not be available in the UK until 2008. The Zune has struggled to find success in the U.S., prompting the postponment of the European launch.

Robbie Bach, the President of Microsoft's Entertainment and Devices Division, described the Zune's 10 percent market share in the US as "not an overwhelming start." However, at the time of writing, Microsoft is refusing to rule out a 2007 release.

Latest in AV
Amazon Spring Deal Days 2025 promotional image with Amazon boxes
Amazon Big Spring Sale live: our TV and headphone experts’ real-time buying advice
A render of a couple watching TV in a living room with green beams used to illustrate the sound coming from the soundbar and various other speakers.
Eclipsa Audio: everything you need to know about Samsung’s new Dolby Atmos rival
Samsung QN990F 8K TV with Rewind logo
A sneak peek at Samsung’s futuristic projector, OLED TV’s next evolution, a new Audiolab stereo amp and more
Sony RGB arrangement with Rewind logo
A sneak peek at Sony's next-gen TV tech, our love letter to hi-fi shops, a high-end amp tested and more
LG C5 on stand with Rewind logo
The LG C5 OLED TV tested, a world first for headphones, new hi-fi speakers and more
Pick Of The Month March 2025 5-star products on grey background
WiiM strikes again, the B&W Zeppelin Pro impresses while Technics' latest turntable earns five-stars
Latest in News
Sony WF-C710N earbuds lined up in different finishes
They’re official! Sony finally takes the wraps off its WF-C710N budget wireless earbuds
A flower on a TV screen with a gem in the middle.
TCL's new Mini LED TV range comes with huge brightness gains, reduced blooming and souped-up sound
Sony WH-1000XM4 on a table with a plant
Some of our favourite-ever five-star wireless headphones have plummeted to nearly half price – £172 off!
RCA Roku TV 24-inch (RK24HF1) small TV
My favourite kitchen TV has dropped to under £100 for Amazon Spring Deal Days
Sony XR-48A90K
Amazon has slashed the price of this five-star Sony OLED, but we have found an even better deal
Fiio FX17 in-ear headphones
Fiio's flagship in-ear headphones are packed full of drivers to put your music in pole position