Music industry seeks judicial review over CD and DVD copying decision

Prior to 1st October, it had actually been unlawful to make copies of physical media to listen to or watch back on a digital platform under the terms of the UK's copyright law – even if you were the rightful owner of that media.

That is no longer the case, but now UK Music, the Musicians Union and the British Academy of Songwriters, Composers and Authors have joined forces to apply for a judicial review into the introduction of the legislation.

MORE: UK government legalises CD, DVD and Blu-ray copying for personal use

The organisations accepted "the purpose" of the measures, but argued that it doesn't provide fair compensation to songwriters, musicians and other rights holders – something they say is at the heart of European law.

It has been argued that the UK government has differed from "the vast majority of countries in Europe" that have also introduced private copying exceptions, specifically with regards to the "compensatory mechanism".

UK Music CEO Jo Dipple said: "Licensing is the business model for the UK music industry’s success in the digital age. However, where the right to licence is removed rights holders should be compensated."

MORE: To rip or not to rip, that is the question

British Academy of Songwriters, Composers and Authors CEO Vick Bain added: "We have sought judicial review because of the way the government made its decision not to protect the UK’s creative industries."

Under the amended exceptions to copyright, you can now copy your CDs, DVDs or Blu-rays and transfer that material to digital devices, as well as also being permitted to digitally back-up your collection.

The change to copyright law had been had been due to come into effect on 1st June, in wake of 2011's Hargreaves Review – but the move had been placed on hold for four months. An explanation for why can be found here.

MORE: Digital sales of music and movies on the rise, but Blu-ray holds its own

Pete was content editor on What Hi-Fi?, overseeing production and publication of digital content. In creating and curating feature articles for web and print consumption, he provided digital and editorial expertise and support to help reposition What Hi-Fi? as a ‘digital-first’ title; reflecting the contemporary media trends. He is now a senior content strategist. 

Latest in Streaming & Entertainment
Kolkata Knight Riders' Rinku Singh plays a shot during the Indian Premier League (IPL) Twenty20 cricket match between Gujarat Titans and Kolkata Knight Riders at the Narendra Modi Stadium in Ahmedabad on April 9, 2023. (Photo by INDRANIL MUKHERJEE / AFP) (Photo by INDRANIL MUKHERJEE/AFP via Getty Images)
IPL live stream 2025: how to watch Indian Premier League cricket online from anywhere, teams, schedule
Qobuz
Qobuz reveals average payout per stream – and claims it is higher than rivals
George Benson Give Me the Night album cover
This Quincy Jones-produced disco tune has become my go-to test track – and taught me a valuable lesson about hi-fi, too
A woman flicking through stacks of vinyl records in a Rough Trade shop.
Vinyl records and music streaming both hit landmark highs – but the one growing faster in revenue may surprise you
Google TV Streamer video streamer
Google TV Streamer
McLaren’s Lando Norris leads a restart on a wet track at the Australian Grand Prix in Melbourne
Chinese Grand Prix 2025 live stream: how to watch the F1 online from anywhere – Lights Out!
Latest in News
Audiolab 6000A MkII amplifier in silver
Audiolab upgrades its five-star 6000A amplifier with a new DAC chip, enhanced circuitry and HDMI ARC
Qobuz
Qobuz reveals average payout per stream – and claims it is higher than rivals
Sonos Beam Gen 2
Quick! This five-star Sonos Dolby Atmos soundbar has dropped close to its lowest price
The Google Pixel 9a being held horizontally at waist-height so only the back is visible.
The Google Pixel 9a launches at £100 less than the iPhone 16e with a better screen
A woman flicking through stacks of vinyl records in a Rough Trade shop.
Vinyl records and music streaming both hit landmark highs – but the one growing faster in revenue may surprise you
Vertere DG X turntable in black finish
Vertere's gorgeous DG X turntable features significant updates for a more refined performance overall