Ford and General Motors face legal action over in-car CD ripping technology

The Alliance of Artists and Recording Companies (AARC) - a non-profit group that represents over 300,000 artists - has filed the lawsuit against Ford and GM and the manufacturers' infotainment suppliers - namely Denso and Clarion.

The lawsuit focuses on Ford's "Jukebox" feature and GM's "Hard Drive Device", features that allow users to rip and store content from a CD on to an internal hard drive. The AARC says these fall under the Audio Home Recording Act, which states that companies need to pay royalties on "digital audio recording devices".

According to the AARC, neither Ford nor GM have paid any royalties for installing the devices - found on vehicles such as the Ford Taurus, Ford Explorer, Chevrolet Volt and GMC Terrain. Denso and Clarion are also required to pay royalties as suppliers of the CD-players, says the AARC.

AARC Executive Director Linda Bocchi says: "22 years ago, co-operation between music creators and device manufacturers resulted in legislation that led to a digital electronics revolution. But having reaped the benefits of this bargain, Ford, GM, Denso and Clarion have now decided to ignore their obligations to music creators and declare themselves above the law.

"While no-one likes legislation, Ford, GM, Denso and Clarion have stonewalled long enough, and we are determined to collect the royalties of our members - and all artists and music creators with rights under the AHRA - are owed."

Artists and record labels are seeking both actual and statutory damages, which could stretch to hundred of millions of dollars. Not only this, but they want to prevent the manufacturers from installing the unauthorised devices in their vehicles. It should be noted that a computer's CD-ripping capabilities don't fall under the same law, because the computer is not marketed as a musical recording device.

GM has yet to comment, but a Ford spokesperson says: "We believe we fully comply with all of our contracts. We are currently exploring the case and have nothing further to share at this time."

MORE: 13 car audio milestones from AM to MP3

Max Langridge

Max is a staff writer for What Hi-Fi?'s sister site, TechRadar, in Australia. But being the wonderful English guy he is, he helps out with content across a number of Future sites, including What Hi-Fi?. It wouldn't be his first exposure to the world of all things hi-fi and home cinema, as his first role in technology journalism was with What Hi-Fi? in the UK. Clearly he pined to return after making the move to Australia and the team have welcomed him back with arms wide open.

Latest in AV
Google TV Streamer on a white background
Google TV's latest update adds a secret feature that could hint towards new hardware
iPhone 16e in black and white on a white background
Apple Event 2025: the new iPhone 16e (not SE 4), but no new HomePod or AirPods
LG QNED91 65-inch LCD TV
HDMI 2.2: everything you need to know about the new TV connection
Sky Glass Gen 2 on stand with Rewind logo
Rewind: hi-fi treats from McIntosh and TEAC, Sky Glass TV Gen 2, Apple launch announcement and more
Apple HomePod 2
3 Apple audio and home cinema products we want, but probably won't see, at the iPhone SE 4's anticipated launch
Samsung HW-Q990F soundbar package on a grey backdrop sitting below a TV
Google and Samsung’s Dolby Atmos rival should be coming to Android TVs, too
Latest in News
Musical Fidelity B1xi
Musical Fidelity's new stereo amplifier houses HDMI ARC and a built-in phono stage
A close-up of the FiiO FT7 headphones' earcups.
FiiO's FT7 flagship headphones take the fight to pricier rivals
A grey WiiM Vibelink Amp on a wooden cabinet between two bookshelf speakers.
The WiiM Vibelink Amp is WiiM's first integrated amp with no streaming elements
Q Acoustics 3050i
Save £650 on this five-star Q Acoustics 5.1 home cinema setup
Optoma Photon Go on white background
Optoma's new on-the-go projector is set to be one of the cheaper USTs on the market
Marantz Cinema 30 AVR
Our Award-winning reference Marantz AVR is still selling at its best price ever