$1bn Apple iPod lawsuit starts – but suffers significant setback

According to the Wall Street Journal, the case is based around the claim that the Cupertino giant deleted audio files downloaded from competing music services between 2007 and 2009 without telling users.

Jurors were reportedly told that people who had downloaded music from a rival service received an error message when syncing their iPod with their iTunes library, which suggested restoring the factory settings on the iPod.

This action allegedly removed music downloaded from rival services, something the lawsuit's plaintiffs see as a move that "stifled competition". The claim is for $350m in damages, which could then triple due to antitrust laws.

Latest developments from the US, however, have cast doubt over the likely success of the action. The Washington Post reports that Apple has produced evidence to suggest two plaintiffs aren't covered by the action.

MORE: Apple buys Beats for $3bn

And a further setback was encountered yesterday [8th December] after the New York Times said the one remaining plaintiff in the case had also been disqualified – leaving lawyers searching for new plaintiffs.

The New York Times reports that federal judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers disagreed with Apple after it argued that it was "too late" to secure new plaintiffs to fight the case – although lawyers do not have much time.

As it stands, the lawsuit is still being fought but it still remains to be seen whether lawyers will be able to find new plaintiffs to continue the action against Apple. The case continues.

MORE: Best music streaming services 2014 – comparison review

MORE: Read all our Apple reviews and news

[via Wall Street Journal/Washington Post/New York Times]

Pete was content editor on What Hi-Fi?, overseeing production and publication of digital content. In creating and curating feature articles for web and print consumption, he provided digital and editorial expertise and support to help reposition What Hi-Fi? as a ‘digital-first’ title; reflecting the contemporary media trends. He is now a senior content strategist. 

Latest in Portable Music Players
Activo P1 hi-res music player
Activo P1
Fiio CP13 and DM13 with CD and cassette cases
Gimmick or Godsend? I spent a week with FiiO’s retro cassette deck and Discman to test their modern-day merit
Volumio Rivo Plus
This slimline, compact network player aims to deliver all your modern-day streaming needs
iPod MP3 digital music
Portable audio peaked 14 years ago – is it time to come full circle?
Astell & Kern A&Ultima SP3000M next to books
Astell & Kern claims that its latest premium portable player is "the world's finest"
Astell & Kern A&norma SR35
Best portable music player 2024
Latest in News
Sony WF-C710N earbuds lined up in different finishes
They’re official! Sony finally takes the wraps off its WF-C710N budget wireless earbuds
A flower on a TV screen with a gem in the middle.
TCL's new Mini LED TV range comes with huge brightness gains, reduced blooming and souped-up sound
Sony WH-1000XM4 on a table with a plant
Some of our favourite-ever five-star wireless headphones have plummeted to nearly half price – £172 off!
RCA Roku TV 24-inch (RK24HF1) small TV
My favourite kitchen TV has dropped to under £100 for Amazon Spring Deal Days
Sony XR-48A90K
Amazon has slashed the price of this five-star Sony OLED, but we have found an even better deal
Fiio FX17 in-ear headphones
Fiio's flagship in-ear headphones are packed full of drivers to put your music in pole position