Is hi-fi getting better? The What Hi-Fi? team wants to know your thoughts!

Naim amp with Ask the Reader logo
(Image credit: What Hi-Fi?)

Welcome to the first entry, and question, in the What Hi-Fi? team’s new Ask The Reader column.

In the new monthly series, we’ll pose a big question about hi-fi or home cinema at the start of the month to you our lovely readers – who, as we know from your feedback on social media and comments in our forums, are a passionate bunch with some great hot takes.

After that we’ll collate the best answers and turn them into a feature detailing your and our opinions on the topic, hopefully offering plenty of food for thought for everyone from the vinyl-curious youngsters to long-toothed audiophiles as a result.

To kick us off, we’re posting a key question posed by our longstanding hi-fi veteran and technical editor, Ketan Bharadia in his last Mutterings From The Test Room column. Specifically:

Is hi-fi really getting better?

This is a key, but complex question many of us ponder, especially when considering whether to upgrade our much-loved separates rack, or build a new system entirely. And the answer is very difficult, which is why we want your input!

Are you on team yes? If so, what proof have you got?

Have you just upgraded your system or gotten a new pair of speakers that offers significant sonic improvements on your older hardware?

Or is it due to the increasingly common appearance of streaming platforms, which make it much easier to access music?

If you’re in the no camp, why?

Is it because, despite frequent trips to your local hi-fi dealer, you’re yet to find a combination, or product, that actually improves the tried and tested system you’ve had back home for years, or even decades? Or do you have an even stronger opinion and think hi-fi is getting worse?

Whatever your answer, let us know your opinion in our forums, on social media or directly with a message to our Whathifi@futurenet.com shared inbox.

Our only request is to remember to keep all messages PG-13! If you include swears we won’t be able to feature your comments in the final article.

If you’re particularly keen to get your thoughts shared with the world and happy to submit them, we’d also love to see photos of your set-up to use in the piece.

Thanks in advanced for all the great thoughts you'll share!

MORE:

These are the best stereo amps we’ve reviewed

We rate the best speakers of all time

Check out the What Hi-Fi? Hall of Fame

Alastair Stevenson
Editor in Chief

Alastair is What Hi-Fi?’s editor in chief. He has well over a decade’s experience as a journalist working in both B2C and B2B press. During this time he’s covered everything from the launch of the first Amazon Echo to government cyber security policy. Prior to joining What Hi-Fi? he served as Trusted Reviews’ editor-in-chief. Outside of tech, he has a Masters from King’s College London in Ethics and the Philosophy of Religion, is an enthusiastic, but untalented, guitar player and runs a webcomic in his spare time. 

Read more
Ask the Reader logo with Technics Turntable
We asked if hi-fi is getting better and ignited a vinyl vs CD format war
KEF Reference 104/2 floorstanders
Is hi-fi really getting better? Our technical editor ponders its progression
Back Issues lead shot with covers of February 2005 and February 2025 magazines
20 years ago: plasma TVs, budget speakers and a very different kind of surround sound package
Zeppelin Pro with in for review
In for Review: the B&W Zeppelin Pro Edition, Theatre Bar 8 and more tested
Rear panel connections of a Michell preamp
It's not always about sound quality; sometimes it's the small things that make using a hi-fi product such a joy
Standmount speakers: KEF LSX II LT
Thinking about getting into hi-fi in the new year? The streamlined system trend is the place to start
Latest in Hi-Fi
Lumin U2 Mini network streamer
Lumin U2 Mini
Pro-Ject AC/DC Turntable
Pro-Ject's AC/DC Turntable wants to put your vinyl on the highway to heaven, not hell
Mixx Revival 65 Turntable
Mixx’s Revival 65 turntable blends vintage charm with modern connectivity
Roksan Atessa Streaming Amplifier in black finish on wooden rack
Roksan’s stylish Attessa Streaming Amplifier is rocking a cool £300 off thanks to this juicy deal
WiiM Ultra music streamer
WiiM Ultra
Audio Research Reference 330M floating on a black background
Audio Research’s new flagship monoblock power amp is a serious high-end powerhouse
Latest in Features
movie still showing a woman holding a baby in a garden
6 classic Best Sound Oscar-winning movies to test-drive your AV system
Sony WF-C700N held in the hand
I can’t wait for the new flagship Sony wireless earbuds – but I’m more excited about its rumoured cheaper pair
Fyne Audio F501E floorstanding speakers
Fyne Audio ousts Q Acoustics as our new favourite sub-£1000 floorstanding speakers
better man movie still of the monkey surrounded by cameras
3 Oscar-nominated movies to make your home cinema feel like a winner
In For Review logo over yellow turntable system on table
In for Review: Google’s latest streamer, a Pro-Ject turntable, Cyrus' premium CD player and more
Wooden speakers in listening room with Rewind logo
Rewind: our verdict on the WiiM Ultra, ProAc D20R, Sony Bravia Projector 8 and more
  • Kenneth Fernandes
    It’s got to do by replacing current analogue-digital combi Studio Mixing consoles with all digital ones in the control room in modern Recording Studios worldwide.
    Reply
  • dananski
    I think hifi equipment is getting better, but the broader picture is mixed.

    For me, I love a neutral sound - where everything is audible in balance and timbre is true to real life. Manufacturers who tailor to that have become better and better at delivering this, at lower and lower prices. My marvellous Chord Mojo sits in a drawer, rendered obsolete by a tiny £40 dongle containing a top notch DAC and headphone amp. My main speakers now sound even better than my excellent 2013 setup, at just a fifth the price. Software like Roon and REW makes lossless playback and live DSP trivial everywhere. More than all this, information is abundant and precise, from tutorials to suites of in-depth measurements. There's no magic to it except the music.

    But even if you like a bit of magic in your hifi, or your own house sound, there's more good options around a huge selection of fun things to mess around with - DIY, cheap valve amps galore, high quality ladder DACs and a resurgence of vinyl.

    Alongside both the fun tinkering stuff and the super-transparent systems, there's still plenty of totally unarguable snake oil and misinformation to extort money from consumers: Expensive cables (and cable risers), unnecessary isolators and power treatments. The positive is I see much more thorough debunking of these things nowadays and I'm hopeful they will eventually disappear for good.

    But the music scene now is different. Huge quantities of music are made continually. A lot of it is excellent, but with the amount to wade through it takes time to find. It's hard to strike a balance of variety and familiarity; most people will just resort to others' playlists on Spotify, often more as background noise than a primary focus. Production is better than ever in high end studios, but a lot of less-mainstream music is made at home and mixed poorly on headphones or small desktop monitors, which means high fidelity playback isn't even really relevant for it. That said, it's fantastic people can do what they now can at home on a tight budget, free from labels and the industry.

    The biggest growing detractor of hifi in my opinion is the cost. Even though it's so much cheaper now, it's more about what money people have spare. There's better and better systems for under £500 or £1000, but fewer and fewer people who can justify or afford even that after their essentials. I am concerned that the 'hifi' journey for many newcomers will only go as far as a mediocre pair of wireless headphones or earbuds. At least these too are improving.
    Reply
  • FreakyDeaky
    For over 100 years the reproduction of audio recordings has always kept improving, riding on the back of technological change. From wax cylinders to SACD, from Audio Cassette to DAT.

    New materials and new ways of delivering music has (and always will) deliver better and better quality.

    These days we have wireless speakers which are excellent, offering great value and perfect for outdoors, parties and casual listening. The arrival of cheap chip amps coupled with a set of budget speakers offer an amazing experience for a fraction of the price of a budget system from 20 years ago.

    But what does this really mean? So the low end of the market has seen incredible leaps forward, but what about the mid to high end?

    There will always be those who search for the Holy Grail, a money no object set up which undoubtedly sounds incredible, but for most of us who don’t have the budget for a dedicated listening room at home, a good quality system that sounds “right” is what we are looking for.

    And I think that is the point. It’s about the sound.

    Example: You have the Naim camp here and the Cyrus camp there, and they will both tell you why their chosen brand has the edge. But who is right?

    All of them of course, like the music we enjoy, it’s all about how it sounds to you.

    So yes HiFi has gotten “better”, but does it matter? Maybe not so much.
    Reply
  • Kenneth Fernandes
    FreakyDeaky said:
    So yes HiFi has gotten “better”, but does it matter? Maybe not so much.
    Yes, it matters a lot. And there will be continued development of how music is captured, recorded and reproduced.
    Reply