I switched from Spotify to Apple Music with this app that saved my playlists (and my sanity)

Apple Music Voice Plan
(Image credit: Apple)

I find myself swapping streaming music apps often these days. Perhaps it's due to the fact that I've been exposed to higher-calibre services that already deliver on the promises of the still absent Spotify HiFi tier, or maybe it's down to having access to more prestigious audio kit that deserves a platform capable of delivering better quality audio; either way, I am once again branching out after yet another year-long courtship with Spotify

I'm bound to return to the platform at some point – I've already made it clear that its playlists and social features always draw me back in – but for now, I've found myself using Apple Music. I wasn't necessarily in the market for a new streaming service, however, a pop-up offering me two months of free Apple Music when I opened the app was all the persuasion I needed. It's been a while since I last used Apple Music, roughly three years if I had to make an educated guess, but the user interface was as slick and inviting as I remember it being. 

There was just one issue; my music library was empty, as Apple rather cheekily clears your library when you stop paying. The thought of starting all over again was excruciating, and truthfully I almost threw in the towel here. However, I decided to look into ways to transfer my music library before giving up on the first hurdle. This is when I found Playlisty for Apple Music on the iOS App Store, and it appeared as though my prayers had been answered. 

The appeal of this app is being able to seamlessly transfer playlists from Spotify to Apple Music; you just need to connect your accounts to the app and it will match the songs in your Spotify library to the equivalent versions on Apple Music. It's as simple as clicking your playlist, and then clicking the "save to your library".

Playlisty app on an iPhone with a white background

Playlisty allows you to import from a variety of sources (and no, this is not my music library). (Image credit: Obdura)

Before committing to the playlist the app has created, you can click on individual songs to find different versions of it; for example remastered tracks or deluxe versions of albums. Its song-matching capabilities are genuinely impressive and, while it's not perfect, it's much easier than adding each song individually; it will even filter songs that it can't find into a separate list so you can add them manually. 

There's also no pressure to save a playlist created on Playlisty, as the "listen without saving" button will create a queue of the tracks you've transferred on the Apple Music app. There's even a Shazam button baked directly into the app, which is handy for adding spur-of-the-moment tracks to your playlist before transferring it. 

It's worth noting that it's not just Spotify playlists that this app works for, as Deezer, YouTube and Soundcloud playlists can also be imported – fingers crossed for Tidal and Amazon Music support in the future. Playlisty also seemingly allows you to upload local files to your Apple Music library too, and the app boasts a wide variety of file types. Admittedly, this isn't a feature I've used yet, but it's a noteworthy edition nonetheless. 

So, what happens when I inevitably end up back on Spotify? Thankfully, there is a Playlisty for Spotify app which does the reverse of the "for Apple Music" version. That's already eased the pressure for me, as I know I can keep my music library updated when jumping between the services. 

And at £2.99 for each, I have no issue paying for the convenience, as this is a one-off in-app purchase and not some sneaky subscription that slowly saps away at my bank account. If you're thinking of jumping ship from Spotify (something we strongly recommend more than ever) then this app is nothing short of a lifesaver. 

MORE:

Check out our picks for the best music streaming services

As well as the best wireless earbuds

And our full Apple Music review

Senior Staff Writer

Lewis Empson is a Senior Staff Writer on What Hi-Fi?. He was previously Gaming and Digital editor for Cardiff University's 'Quench Magazine', Lewis graduated in 2021 and has since worked on a selection of lifestyle magazines and regional newspapers. Outside of work, he enjoys gaming, gigs and regular cinema trips.

Read more
Spotify SCREENSHOT
Best free music apps 2025: free ways to stream music on Android and iPhone
The Samsung Galaxy S22 Plus held in front of a yellow surface. On screen is 'Heat Waves' by Glass Animals on Tidal.
Best music streaming services 2025: free streams to hi-res audio
Hi-res music streaming services compared
Hi-res music streaming services compared: is Tidal, Qobuz, Amazon or Apple Music better?
phone and headphones on a sofa
6 free audiophile apps to supercharge your hi-fi experience
Best spatial audio tracks on Apple Music to try
14 of the best spatial audio tracks in Dolby Atmos on Apple Music
Portable music player: Sony NW-A306
Best Apple iPod Touch alternatives 2025: budget and premium models tested by our experts
Latest in Music Streaming
Qobuz
Qobuz reveals average payout per stream – and claims it is higher than rivals
George Benson Give Me the Night album cover
This Quincy Jones-produced disco tune has become my go-to test track – and taught me a valuable lesson about hi-fi, too
A woman flicking through stacks of vinyl records in a Rough Trade shop.
Vinyl records and music streaming both hit landmark highs – but the one growing faster in revenue may surprise you
Apple Music Classical
Apple Music Classical lands on the web – but there's bad news for Mac users
Nirvana In Utero album cover
11 of the best closing tracks for testing your headphones or hi-fi system
Spotify updates its homescreen
An agonising timeline of our eight-year wait for lossless Spotify HiFi streaming
Latest in Features
LG OLED42C3 and OLED65C3 in What Hi-Fi? test rooms
Amazon has slashed the price of a five-star LG OLED TV for its Spring Sale – but I wouldn't buy it
an array of products assembled on a grey background
We've built an affordable, all-purpose hi-fi system for vinyl, streaming and even headphone fans
A WiiM streamer in action
We asked hi-fi engineers what makes a music streamer sound great – and it's about much more than just chipsets
LG C5 55-inch OLED TV
Now is a great time to buy a new OLED TV, but not a 2025 model
George Benson Give Me the Night album cover
This Quincy Jones-produced disco tune has become my go-to test track – and taught me a valuable lesson about hi-fi, too
Samsung QN990F 8K TV with Rewind logo
A sneak peek at Samsung’s futuristic projector, OLED TV’s next evolution, a new Audiolab stereo amp and more