Disney Plus' next move has made me question my streaming choices

Disney Plus' next move has made me question my streaming choices
(Image credit: Future)

More bad news from the streaming world – Disney+ is clamping down on password sharing. As if regular price rises and the addition of adverts in the US weren't bad enough, the House of Mouse is now following Netflix in stopping users sharing their accounts with anyone outside their household. (Or should that be mousehold?) Which has made me take a long, hard look at the family finances.

Don't tell anyone, but I've been sharing a friend's account for going on three years now. And like many families up and down the country, we have to think carefully about whether we can afford yet another monthly outgoing, especially for something as superfluous as a streaming service. 

The price is right

I'd hate to lose it. Disney+ has become one of our most-used apps. Not only is it one of the best streaming services for kids, with the full library of Bluey on hand to calm any tantrums (along with less edifying fare like Super Kitties and Spidey and His Amazing Friends), there's also plenty for grown-ups, like The Mandalorian, The Banshees of Inisherin, The Bear, Hamilton and WandaVision. No wonder it won a 2022 What Hi-Fi? Award. And I haven't paid a penny for it.

Which has been mostly great. I say mostly, because there is one niggle. It's a US account I'm sharing, which means the library doesn't match up with the UK Disney+. I searched in vain for Welcome to Wrexham, for example, before realising it's on Hulu in the US. I know, break out the tiny violin.

Over the years, I reckon I've saved over £200 thanks to password sharing. But the gravy train could soon be derailed.

No free lunch

Future

(Image credit: Future)

Disney's CEO Bob Iger recently revealed the firm was "actively exploring" ways to stop password sharing (via The Motley Fool). It's hardly surprising. Netflix made the same move earlier this summer – now, if you want to share your account with someone outside your household, you have to add them as a separate member for £4.99 / $7.99 / AU$7.99 a month. And it paid off. Since the move, Netflix added nearly 6 million extra customers. Is it any wonder Disney+ wants to do the same?

The one upside is that Disney's crackdown will take some time to implement. Iger said the firm will update its policies later this year, and "roll out tactics to drive monetization sometime in 2024".

But it likely won't happen until the year after.

"In calendar '24, we're going to get at this issue," Iger went on. "And so while it is likely you'll see some impact in calendar '24, it's possible that we won't be complete or the work will not be completed within the calendar year."

In other words, it probably won't ban password sharing until 2025. Which gives me a year and some change to try and rebalance the family finances. 

A bubble about to burst?

I wonder how many other households are having similar conversations. We currently have Sky Q with Netflix, Prime Video as part of Amazon Prime and Disney+, yet the majority of our viewing is still the terrestrial channels. Add Apple TV+ for completeness, and the costs soon add up – you could be looking at a monthly bill of around £60. And that's not including some of the lesser known services like Mubi, Shudder and Crunchyroll.

You don't need me to tell you that despite inflation falling, everything is still getting more expensive (including essentials like petrol, energy prices and food) just at a slower rate. With streaming services also putting up prices, something has to give.

Just in the UK, Netflix has raised its prices six times in seven years, and as recent industry moves have shown, where Netflix leads the others tend to follow. Streamers promised us a radical new world of entertainment, and while their rapid rise has reshaped the televisual landscape, I wonder if we're living through more of a bubble than a bona fide revolution. They're already adding adverts and stopping password sharing, which were two of the biggest draws to streaming in the first place. How long is the current model sustainable?

MORE:

Disney+ slashes 75% off the price of a three-month subscription for a limited time

Check out the best streaming services for movies and TV shows

Binge big: 8 Netflix and Amazon Prime Video streaming service alternatives

Netflix and Disney Plus might be convenient, but I will never part with my DVD collection

Joe Svetlik

Joe has been writing about tech for 17 years, first on staff at T3 magazine, then in a freelance capacity for Stuff, The Sunday Times Travel Magazine, Men's Health, GQ, The Mirror, Trusted Reviews, TechRadar and many more (including What Hi-Fi?). His specialities include all things mobile, headphones and speakers that he can't justifying spending money on.

  • Geoff-W
    So you've been sponging off a friend's account to the tune of £200? For those of us who are honest enough to not engage in such dubious practices, our moral stance would cost us a lot of money per month to sign up to streaming services. That is why I have never signed up to any of them, knowing they will continually ramp up the fee year on year.
    I hope all the streaming services ban the password-sharing loophole - then you might realise the true cost to everybody else.
    Reply
  • spuckle
    I'd have ditched it but it's free if you have enough Tesco Clubcard vouchers every 3 months...
    Reply
  • davidf
    I’ve been debating most of this year whether or not to continue with streaming services or just reply on physical media.

    I‘m all about physical media, but streaming comes in handy for watching films you‘re not comfortable paying money for, or just watching something for something’s sake becaise as a film fan you know you have got to watch it.

    Despite that, I currently subscribe to Amazon Prime, Netflix, Shudder, Disney+, and Arrow. I dip in and out of Mubi and I’ve tried Apple TV and Paramount+ which didn’t have enough for me to continue paying for them. Also used to have a Cineworld Unlimited card but I stopped that about a year ago because there wasn’t enough on frequently enough (due to lockdown and film releases being suspended).

    There is only so much you can stomach paying for, even for a film fan like myself who watches between 600-1000 films a year. My first year of Disney+ comes to an end this monthl and while there’s still some stuff in my watchlist to get through, I won’t get through it all. Shame. Prime has the biggest warchlist to get through, so I can justify keeping that. Shudder and Arrow I might go back to every so often if I need to, and Netflix I can take or leave, but I kept it going a year or so ago because I‘d only watched the forst two series of Stranger Things, and I hadn’t watched the second series of Mindhunter. I’d drop it right now if I could buy all the Stranger Things in 4K for a sensible price. Might have to just settle for Bluray, which will still be better quality than 4K streaming anyway.

    Every time I think of a film I want to watch that I don’t have, I can never find it anywhere on any of those five streaming services, it’s always on one I haven’t got - except to buy or rent, and I’m not paying even more money to rent, and I’m certainly not “buying” a film online for a tenner or more when I don’t actually own it and never will. I buy the odd film on iTunes if I really need to, but I never pay more than £5, and I’ll only pay that much if the film has only ever been released on DVD and the going rate on eBay is upwards of £20, or the limited Bluray release costs even more. I reckon I’m paying about £50 a month for streaming services, and I’m seriously thinking of halting them all and just spending that money on physical media. If I purchase Blurays I haven’t seen before within the £50/month, even if they turn out to be naff I’m not out of pocket, and I’ll get something back off them if I sell them on. I won’t include the expensive limited 4K sets I’ve been buying, as they’re my favourite films and I know I’ll get my money’s worth from them - stuff like the up and coming 4K Arrow box sets like Blood And Black Lace, Hellraiser, and Psycho. Other releases I’ll wit for the standard 4K releases to drop to under £15 or become part of a 2 for £20/25 offer. The only “box set” I bought on iTunes was Transformers, because I wasn’t going to pay £120, particularly as most of them are a bit pants. They came up on iTunes quite cheap in 4K so I thought I’d go for it. I switched off half way through the second one as they just had no bass. Their soundtrack had been altered to keep TV speakers and crappy soundbars safe (an increasingly common thing nowadays). That was a waste of money that won’t happen again.

    Sure, I’ll end up with less space (a Kaleidoscape is tempting!), but at least I’ll have what I want to watch when I want to watch it. Browsing through Netflix recently I saw Knives Out: Glass Onion in the listing, so I thought I’d watch the two Knives Out movies again - but they don’t have the first film available! Last night I rewatched Wonderland, a TV movie about the Wonderland Murders in the 70s which involved the porn star John Holmes, and I thought I’d watch Boogie Nights tonight, as I haven’t seen it for years, and it’s based on John Holmes. Can I find it anywhere? No! So jumped online, Amazon, £7.98, it’ll be here tomorrow. Wasn’t any cheaper on eBay, but many films are available from World Of Books or Music Magpie on eBay for a few quid. Bought a number of 3D Blurays through them recently.

    So by the end of this year, I could well be streaming service free. I think I’d rather pay zero money to streaming services (because their quality is a backwards step), and out my money into films I own and back into a Cineworld Unlimited card now cinemas have got back to normal. At least it’s doing something to help find cinemas, which are far more important to me than cash-grab streaming services. At least an average quality cinema is a real “experience” that no streaming service can provide.
    Reply
  • Arron
    davidf said:
    I’ve been debating most of this year whether or not to continue with streaming services or just reply on physical media.

    I‘m all about physical media, but streaming comes in handy for watching films you‘re not comfortable paying money for, or just watching something for something’s sake becaise as a film fan you know you have got to watch it.
    Couple of fun Life Hacks... well, fun to me:

    If you have a Plex Server, buying new matters far less. So sources of used discs like Music Magpie, Ebay, CEX, charity shops, etc. become a cheap way to build a big collection. Discs go in a box in the loft once ripped.

    If you cancel Prime, after 8-9 months they get itchy and offer you a 30 day free trial. Time it right and start the trial around the first of December. That way you can get presents delivered for free and catch up on the few Amazon exclusives over Christmas. Then decline the trial at the end. Rinse and repeat next year :D
    Reply
  • davidf
    Arron said:
    Couple of fun Life Hacks... well, fun to me:

    If you have a Plex Server, buying new matters far less. So sources of used discs like Music Magpie, Ebay, CEX, charity shops, etc. become a cheap way to build a big collection. Discs go in a box in the loft once ripped.

    If you cancel Prime, after 8-9 months they get itchy and offer you a 30 day free trial. Time it right and start the trial around the first of December. That way you can get presents delivered for free and catch up on the few Amazon exclusives over Christmas. Then decline the trial at the end. Rinse and repeat next year :D
    Life hack - don’t store your discs in the loft…

    As mentioned, I do use a few places on eBay for Blurays I don’t want to pay more than a fiver for.

    Amazon would be the hardest one for me to cancel, even though I despise Amazon - but they have by far the biggest choice, and the free delivery comes in handy for the odd Bluray or box set.
    Reply
  • robmat
    "I'd hate to lose it. Disney+ has become one of our most-used apps. "
    You've been stealing the service and now you are unhappy that someone is going to take it from you?
    Reply
  • EhCanadian
    As a parent, I disagree: Disney+ is NOT one of the best streaming services for kids. Half their new kids content is series of short films that are over before they begin! Compare that to Netflix which has shows like Peppa Pig, Paw Patrol, and My Little Pony that have 10+ seasons and 100+ episodes, so that my kids can watch everyday and not feel like it's repeating. Disney just doesn't seem to understand how kids watch television - streaming needs long shows to binge. And if we break it down to dollars-per-hour of viewing, or dollars-per-hour of content, Disney+ is far more expensive than Netflix for the amount of content.
    Reply
  • Arron
    davidf said:
    Life hack - don’t store your discs in the loft…
    Don't store discs in the loft because... ?
    Reply
  • davidf
    Arron said:
    Don't store discs in the loft because... ?
    Changeable conditions, potential damp.

    There’s an idea for a mediocre blog for the WHF bots - storing discs. Although, I guess there’s no tagging/linking potential in something like that.
    Reply