ON TEST: Humax's £150 Foxsat HD Freesat set-top box

Andy Clough Thursday, May 08, 2008 15:42

Humax Foxsat Web

We reported on the launch of Freesat earlier this week, and yesterday Humax delivered its Foxsat HD Freesat receiver to our test rooms here at Teddington Studios, writes Andy Clough.

There's been much excitement on our Forums about the new subscription-free high-definition TV service, and we couldn't wait to plug in the box and have a play.

One of the most frequently asked questions here on whathifi.com is "can I buy the box and simply plug it into my existing Sky satellite dish?".

Keen to provide an answer, we plugged the Humax into our Sky satellite socket in the main home cinema test room. The signal strength indicator showed 100 per cent, but signal quality was poor – over the course of two hours, we were only able to get it to work properly three times.

Thinking that there might be a snag with our Sky connection, we moved the set-top box into our smaller TV test room and again connected it to the Sky socket in there. Better luck this time, as we got clear picture and sound.

Just to be sure everything was working correctly, our Editor-in-Chief took the box home last night and plugged it into her Sky dish. There was no problem with the picture, both in standard-def and HD, but using the HDMI socket on the Humax to connect to her Onkyo AV receiver, there was frequent break-up on the sound when watching the HD channels. Mmm, not quite what we expected.

Suspecting that there might be a fault with the Humax box, we contacted the company's PR agency this morning and they sent us a replacement this afternoon.

We've now plugged the second box into the Sky connection in the main AV room, and so far it's worked flawlessly. We'll publish a full review with star rating of the Humax here online in the next couple of days.

[EDIT] Second box also worked perfectly in my Sky system at home, writes Clare Newsome, complete with Dolby Digital 5.1 from BBC HD via an HDMI connection. Still think it should have been a PVR, though....

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Comments

al30tsm May 8, 2008 19:41

Great, looking forward to the review, have Humax mentioned anything about a pvr?

Alsone May 9, 2008 13:02

Its mentioned on the Freesat website but they've removed the Humax model number now.

Rumour has it July but official statement is later this year.

mcefreak May 9, 2008 14:50

I wonder how long we will have to wait for a twin tuner pc card to work with vista mce?

TomWakeland May 9, 2008 16:14

What if you've got a couple of feeds? one to your lounge and one to the bedroom, can you have your sky box plugged into one and a freesat plugged into the other running off the same dish?

Giskard May 9, 2008 20:41

I have a sky+ (with 2 feeds) in the living room, a sky+ box(with 1 feed) in the kitchen/diner and a Humax on the final feed from a quad lnb on my bog standard sky dish.

I have to say the Humax performed spot on straight out of the box, the other sky+ boxes didn't affect the Humax at all. It found all the channels and the BBC HD was a joy to behold (shame it is only on for 4 hrs with real programmes, the rest is demo time).

Would love to have a Freesat Dongle for the Laptop, that would cover all my bases.

The EPG is a little strange when your used to Sky, but you easily get used to it.

My wife, who is no techy at all, was using it quite freely and did not find the navigation too bad.

Overall a very good product, just a shame it was not a pvr.

mring May 10, 2008 05:10

can anyone explain what makes it any different than any other DVB-S HD reciever?

freesat is 100% DVB-S compliant so £150 is allot of money, knowing u can buy a DVB-S HD HDMI compliant decoder for 80 euro's in EuroLand :p

even if it's the guide price it's still high.

installer May 10, 2008 17:59

Reference mring's post dated May 10, 2008; there is quite a difference. If you want Sky's freesat service, the box is again £150... AND IT ISN'T HD! So you have a bonus straight off. Secondly, the EPG of the other boxes currently available show only whats on now, and next only; where as Freesat's receivers have 1 weeks worth. That's a fair bit of difference. If that isn't enough, then buy the cheaper version, download the software with your dish on 28.2 degrees and then turn it to 19 degrees and get approx. 200 stations. As always, you get what you pay for.

trevormed May 10, 2008 18:06

Freesat HD broadcasts are DVB-S2 which I think is an Mpeg4 rather than an Mpeg2 compliant decoder, hence the need for more money. I bought a TT-Connect S2-3600 "box" which plugs into my PC's USB 2.0 port for picking up free to air Satillite channels. This works with BBC-HD, however my machine / Graphics card is not upto the job and the image breaks down every 20 - 100 frames. On the longer run of a few seconds the HD quality comes through.

Now to my question.. This Humax box has a USB connection, but what for? The Ethernet is for interactive services, so that leaves other options. 1 to up date the software, 2 for adding a keyboard for interactive use, 3 to display / play files ie video / photos / music mp3 and/or 4 and what would interest us all... to store the broadcast and hence be a PVR!

felicia May 12, 2008 11:03

in currys at weekend and the have pulled this box of sale due to problems above!!

edinburghphoto May 12, 2008 15:54

Got mine yesterday from Currys! Plugged in into my sky dish and it worked perfectly first time and since. Picture quality seems the same as sky on SD. HD is great. Watched the BBC R1 big weekend live and loved it - thought I was there. I've got a Panasonic plasma with a mediocre sound so I'm using an optical cable to my denon surround sound (Dolby digital).  Roll on itv hd and more...

tnmc May 31, 2008 23:29

I live in an apartment with a shared dish (over 70 flats in the complex) and I only have one satellite point coming into the flat so I couldn't do Sky+ for example.   I've got a regular Sky box though and I've bought this Humax one so I can get HD for the European Championships without paying Sky more money.

My question is, if I put a satellite coax splitter on the wall and fed both boxes independently, would I be able to use them independently?  

I don't need both to work at the same time, only one or the other.

Anonymous comments are disabled

About Andy Clough

Andy Clough is Editor of whathifi.com